3D-printed Aligners vs Thermoformed Aligners: The Future of Orthodontics

In recent years, orthodontics has undergone significant evolution, especially in the field of clear aligners. Two primary methods have emerged for producing these aligners: thermoforming and direct 3D printing. While both techniques aim to provide effective orthodontic treatments, the differences between them are considerable. Upon closer examination of each method's nuances, it becomes clear that 3D-printed aligners are superior, benefiting both patients and practitioners.

‍

What are Thermoformed Aligners?

Thermoformed aligners are orthodontic devices created by molding a sheet of clear plastic over a 3D model of a patient's teeth. The plastic is heated and then vacuum-formed to fit the specific dental structure, which makes these aligners custom-made for each individual. This method has been traditionally used to produce clear aligners and retainers in orthodontic treatments, but new technologies like 3D printing are offering alternative production methods.

‍

‍

The Thermoforming Process = Reliable but Not Perfect

Although thermoforming is a reliable method, it has its limitations:

1. Material: Thermoforming uses plastic sheets that, when heated, can sometimes deform unevenly, leading to inconsistencies in the final product. This variability can affect the fit and therefore the effectiveness of the treatment.
2. Accuracy: The level of detail that thermoforming can capture is limited. This is especially problematic in complex cases that require precise movements of individual teeth. Additionally, undercuts on the model need to be filled in (e.g., with block-out or in the software).
3. Labor-Intensive: The production of thermoformed aligners is labor-intensive and requires multiple steps and manual intervention. Each aligner must be carefully manufactured, which can introduce human errors into the process.
4. Waste Production: Trimming the aligners generates a lot of plastic waste, making thermoforming less environmentally friendly compared to newer methods. Additionally, 3D printing the models also creates a significant amount of waste. Each step in the treatment requires a separate 3D-printed model, which is discarded after thermoforming.

3D-Printed Aligners: The Next Generation

3D printing technology has revolutionized many industries, and dentistry is no exception. 3D-printed aligners are printed directly based on a digital scan of the patient's teeth. This process enables precision and customization that thermoforming simply cannot match.

‍

‍

Benefits of 3D-Printed Aligners

1. Unmatched Precision: 3D printing allows for the creation of aligners with extremely fine details. Each aligner is printed directly from software, ensuring a perfect fit and optimal pressure distribution for tooth movement. This precision translates into more effective treatments and faster results.
2. Material Efficiency: 3D printers use advanced materials specifically designed for orthodontic applications. These materials are engineered for consistent performance, ensuring uniform thickness and strength of the aligner. This consistency enhances the durability and effectiveness of the aligners.
3. Customization and Flexibility: With 3D printing, each aligner can be individually customized (e.g., with a unique number) without additional costs or time. This means that even the most complex orthodontic cases can be treated with high precision. The flexibility of the 3D printing process allows for quick adjustments to the treatment plan, providing a more dynamic and responsive treatment experience.
4. Production Speed: 3D printing streamlines the production process and reduces the time from digital scan (or impression) to final aligner. This speed benefits patients by shortening treatment time and also allows orthodontists to provide more efficient and responsive care. In-house 3D printing even opens the door to "Same Day Dentistry."
5. Eco-Friendly Production: Unlike thermoforming, direct 3D printing generates minimal waste. The process uses only the material needed for the aligner itself, making it a more sustainable choice. There is no need to print separate models, and the sheets are naturally unnecessary. In an industry that is increasingly aware of its environmental impact, this is a significant advantage.

‍

‍

Advantages of 3D-Printed Aligners

1. Advancements in 3D-Printed Aligners: The benefits of 3D-printed aligners go beyond just precision and efficiency. They represent a significant leap forward in dental technology, providing treatments that are more customized, reliable, and environmentally friendly. As the technology evolves, we can expect further innovations in 3D printing, solidifying its position as the superior method for producing clear aligners. This progress leads to more comfortable and effective treatments for patients, better tools for orthodontists to achieve optimal results, and a step toward a future where advanced technology delivers better care for all.
2. Material Efficiency and Performance: The material used to print aligners is highly advanced and meets all necessary biocompatibility standards. Extensive research has made it possible for the material to have "shape memory," meaning it returns to its original 3D-printed shape when heated. This, along with a uniform thickness and ideal material properties, ensures highly efficient treatment and fast, effective results.

‍

Key Points

• Thermoformed aligners are traditional and have limitations in precision, material consistency, and environmental friendliness.
• 3D-printed aligners offer unmatched precision, material efficiency, and customization, with faster production times and minimal waste production.
• 3D printing technology enables dynamic and precise orthodontic treatments, resulting in a better fit and more effective outcomes.
• Environmental Benefit: Direct 3D-printed aligners are more sustainable compared to thermoforming sheets and printing numerous models. This contributes to a more eco-friendly orthodontic practice.
• The future of digital orthodontics lies in 3D-printed aligners, which are superior in nearly every aspect compared to their thermoformed counterparts.

‍

The Power of the All-in-One Sweet Solution

With the All-in-One Sweet Solution, you can design and print customized aligners directly in-house. Experience the precision of Sweeth Shape Memory Clear Aligners—3D-printed to maintain their shape throughout treatment, ensuring accurate results. These high-quality, nearly invisible aligners offer comfort and effectively shift teeth, leading to shorter wait times and full control over the treatment process.

Have you ever considered adding 3D printing to your practice? Book a 15-minute consultation with one of our experts and discover how in-house 3D printing of aligners can enhance your control and profitability.

‍

‍